Interdisciplinary Legal Studies

Interdisciplinary Legal Studies

Ambiguity in the Criteria for Identifying the “Reasonable Person” in Laws and Legal Literature and Its Challenges (A Comparative Study in Iranian and US Law)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Faculty of Law and Theology, Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman, Kerman, Iran.
2 Kerman Province Branch of the Judiciary΄s Member of Center for Attorneys, Official Experts, and Family Counselors, Kerman, Iran.
10.22034/ils.2026.2118644.1005
Abstract
Background and Aim: Fundamental concepts such as custom, the reasonable person, and fault, which serve as key tools for distinguishing criminal from non-criminal acts, appear clear in appearance and theory; however, when applied in judicial practice, they cause ambiguity and confusion for judges and lawyers. Aiming for a comparative study of Iranian and US law, this research investigates the ambiguous criteria for identifying the “reasonable person” and attempts to analyze the consequences of this ambiguity, particularly in the sensitive institution of “lawful defense (self-defense),” which puts the rights of the offender and the victim at high risk of infringement.

Materials and Methods: This research is theoretical in nature and adopts a descriptive-analytical research method.

Findings: The findings indicate that the lack of a precise, objective, and comprehensive definition of the concept of the “reasonable person” in laws and legal literature leads to subjective judgments and inadequate simultaneous protection of the rights of both the victim and the offender in criminal proceedings, especially in cases of lawful defense. Traditional criteria often fail to respond to social changes and the complexities of human behavior.

Ethical Considerations: Throughout all stages of writing this research, originality of texts, honesty, and trustworthiness have been strictly observed.

Conclusion: The results demonstrate that revising and standardizing the criteria for evaluating the reasonable person in the legal systems of Iran and the United States is essential. Reforming these criteria can reduce judicial ambiguities and appropriately safeguard the rights of both parties in criminal cases and lawful defense.
Keywords


Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 19 November 2026

  • Receive Date 18 November 2026
  • Accept Date 19 November 2026
  • First Publish Date 19 November 2026
  • Publish Date 19 November 2026